Sibling Abuse Among Twins

» 3 Comments

Teenage GirlA question was submitted by a thirteen year old girl who is being abused by her twin brother. She is not getting any help from her parents or school counselors. Sibling abuse is very common and I have seen it in my own practice and among children and adults of all ages. Many of the abused siblings feel powerless, suffer alone, and become isolated and ultimately depressed. There are many options available to abused children; the key is to be aware of what options are available.

Dear Doctor Life Advice,

I am a thirteen year old girl and I am having a lot of trouble with my parents and twin brother. My brother started attacking me physically when we were in third grade. I asked my parents for help, but they told me to wait it out and that he would grow out of it. We found out in sixth grade that he has a learning disability. This has given him even more excuses to act out, make a fuss, and hit me. He has also tried to hit our father, but our father is stronger. I even talked to our school’s counselor, but didn’t get any help. My grades are dropping and my parents and I are fighting more because of it. I have been spending more of my time alone in my room. I don’t invite my friends over because I am afraid of my brother’s behavior in front of them. My parents don’t know what else to do because my brother is already seeing a therapist.

Signed: Unsure What To Do

 

Dear Unsure What To Do,

This is a terrible situation you are in, and my heart goes out to you and your parents. Unfortunately, as your brother gets older, he is going to get larger and stronger and the problem will only escalate. The time to act is now, and you will need to make some tough decisions and act strongly. It is important for you to understand a few important facts. First, as tired as your parents are, they have two children, and are obligated by law to protect both of them. It is not an option for your parents to tell you to tough it out, or wait until he grows out of it. They must take all action necessary to keep you safe. Second, you must understand that you are not helpless. The actions that I will advise you to take may seem harsh at first glace, but they will benefit you and the rest of your family in the long run. Third, I want you to know that you are in danger of developing depression. You are already beginning to show early signs such as dropping grades, isolating yourself in your room, and not inviting friends over. Your brother is getting help from a therapist; I think you and your parents should be getting help too. Last but not least, I noticed you didn’t use the word “abuse” in your question. You must understand that your brother’s behavior towards you is abusive. Under no circumstances should he be hitting you, and if he is, then he is abusing you. Here are some options for you to consider. I strongly recommend that you consider doing all of the following.

Document Your Brother’s Behavior

If your brother ever leaves bruises or marks on you when he hits you, take ample pictures of the bruises and marks. Keep a camera with you at all times. Either video or audio tape your brother’s outbursts. You have reached out to others for help and have not been helped. If you can show them what you are going through, the same people will be much more likely to pay serious attention to you.

Talk to Your School Counselor Again

I am shocked that your school counselor did not help you. School counselors are required by law to report abuse to the Child Protective Services (CPS). I can only guess that when you talked to the counselor, she or he did not understand the extent of what you are going through. If your brother is hitting you, and your parents can not protect you, then CPS must get involved. Your brother is not a small child any more and can do real harm. CPS needs to be involved before he becomes dangerous. Talk to your counselor again, and use the word “abuse.” Perhaps that will get his or her attention.

Insist on Talking to Your Brother’s Therapist

Therapists are also obligated by law to report any case of suspected abuse. If your brother is seeing his therapist by himself, then the therapist may be completely unaware of how your brother is treating you. I know that in my practice, if a patient or his family do not give me the crucial information, then my treatment of that patient will be missing key elements. Your brother’s therapist cannot help him with his violent anger outbursts if the therapist does not know about them. Make sure the therapist knows what you are going through.

Make Sure Your Parents Take Your Brother to a Psychiatrist

A psychiatrist is a physician that specializes in the field of psychiatry. Only a physician can prescribe medication to his or her patients. I don’t know how severe your brother’s outbursts are, but from what you have written, I think a psychiatric evaluation is in order. You stated that your brother has a learning disability. How was that determined? Did he see a psychiatrist, and/or did he have formal testing done? Sometimes schools do their own formal testing using the school counselor, and then recommend a therapist. That is very good, however, in this process, the person being tested is never evaluated for the possibility of medication management. If your brother’s behavior is impulsive and severe, he may be suffering from a psychiatric condition that requires medication treatment. In that case, there are medications that help reduce the frequency and severity of episodes of outburst. Your brother needs to be evaluated by a child psychiatrist to determine if medications will help improve his condition.

Insist on Getting Family and/or Personal Therapy

Your parents seem to be at a loss as to what to do. Your brother is getting away with abusing you, and he is even trying to hit your father. If your brother is not stopped, the time will come that he will be strong enough to even over-power your father. I also think that sooner or later he may hit your mother as well. As your brother gets older, your parents will have less and less control over him. They are running out of time, and they need serious help on learning how to deal with his behavior. They must get help. A family therapist will teach your parents to set firm limits for your brother. It will be hard work at first, because your brother won’t like new rules and new limits. Over time, however, he will learn to behave differently and within the limits. I also encourage you to find personal therapy in case my concerns are correct and you are developing depression. A child your age should be out there enjoying her life. Do not let yourself get depressed.

Learn Management of Aggressive Behavior

When I was starting my residency in psychiatry, I was required to take a class called Management of Aggressive Behavior (MAB). This class is similar to self-defense, but the key difference is that the goal of MAB is to learn to protect yourself without hurting your attacker. In self-defense, you assume that you are being attacked by someone malicious that means to intentionally harm you. In MAB, you do not make that assumption; you just learn how to most effectively get away from an attacker. In mental health, we learned MAB because sometimes our patients may get agitated and violent. You have a brother that does the same. You need to learn how to get away from him without either of you getting harmed.

Call the Police Next Time

Inform your brother and the rest of your family that the next time your brother hits you, you will call 911. Make sure they will take you seriously. Remember, if you decide on this path, then you must call the police next time your brother hits you, or your family will never believe you. This action seems harsh. I know you love your family and do not want to get the Police involved. I am hoping that when you inform your family of your intentions, they will take all measures necessary to keep you out of harm’s way. However, if a simple warning is not enough, then involving the authorities will have long term positive effects. This about it this way, calling the police when your brother hits you now will result in the police showing up and diffusing the situation. It will also let your brother and parents know that you are determined not to take any more abuse. On the other hand, if you let your brother’s behavior continue, then there may come a time that the neighbors will call the police, or your brother will do serious harm to someone. Then your brother would face jail time. It is better to show him there are serious consequences to his actions now, before he becomes more dangerous.

Contact Child Protective Services (CPS)

If all else fails, always remember Child Protective Services (CPS). CPS is a government agency that is available in most states. In some states, it may be under a different name, but still will be easy to find. Use any internet search engine and enter the words “child protective services” and the name of your state. People in general are very afraid of calling CPS, because they think that the children will be taken away from their parents. This is a misconception. The goal of CPS is to ensure the safety of the children first within the family home. The first thing they do is interview the children and assess the situation. Usually, a Social Worker or a Case Manager will be assigned to work with the family. They will help the family get the resources they need to keep the children safe. They may even involve the extended family in getting help. Again, your family may resent you in the short term for getting CPS involved, but in the long term, you may be saving the whole family a lot of trouble by preventing your brother from becoming more violent.

In conclusion, I stress again that you are in a very difficult situation. Allowing the abuse to continue is not an option. Your brother and parents will benefit as much as you from stopping the abuse now. You have asked for help without success, it is time to let the grown ups know that you will not tolerate the violence any more.

Doctor Life Advice



2 Comments

  1. sam
    Posted February 1, 2014 at 6:04 pm | Permalink

    Such great advice.I hope she follows it.unfortunately the brother gets more attention than she and she is the one suffering..So sad it breaks my heart..

  2. Cynthia B. Jones
    Posted September 19, 2015 at 5:47 am | Permalink

    Poor kid. Her parents don’t notice that she is also suffering and much much suffering than her brother. We must always communicate with our childrens to understand them better not only prioritizing the one who has a disability every child needs attention or they might go to the wrong way. We must not give up from life problems everything is possible with God.

One Trackback

  1. […] two years ago I wrote a response to a 13 year old girl who was being abused by her twin brother (http://advice.doctorbeheshti.com/sibling-abuse-among-twins/). Recently I received an email from a 16 year old girl with very similar problems. The question […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.



Terms & Conditions of Use


By entering this website you agree to the following terms and conditions:

1. No Medical Advice

The content of www.advice.doctorbeheshti.com site is for informational purposes only. Sayeh Beheshti, MD, Inc. (“SBMD“), operates and owns this site. DOCTOR LIFE ADVICE℠ is a servicemark of SBMD. The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this site.

If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 immediately. This site does not recommend or endorse any specific tests, physicians, products, procedures, opinions, or other information that may be mentioned on the Site. Reliance on any information provided by here, or other visitors to the site is solely at your own risk.

2. Privacy

2.1 Personal Information

If you choose to register with SBMD or access certain functionality on the SBMD Site, you may be required to submit Personal information. “Personal information” means information that we can use to identify or contact you, such as your name, address, telephone number or email address. Some of our interactive tools and services may request you to submit health information, which would also be considered Personal Information. You are responsible for ensuring the accuracy of the Personal information that you submit to SBMD. Inaccurate information will affect your experience when using the SBMD Site and tools and our ability to contact you as described in this Privacy Policy.

2.2 Cookies and Web Beacons

We may collect Non-Personal information about your use of the SBMD Site and your use of other Site through the use of cookies and web beacons. “Cookies” are small data files that are stored on the hard drive of the computer you use to view a web site. Every computer that accesses the SBMD Site is assigned a different cookie by SBMD. “Web Beacons” are graphic image files imbedded in a web page typically used to monitor activity on a web page and send back to its home server (which can belong to the host site, a network advertiser or some other third party) information from your browser, such as the IP address, the URL of the page on which the beacon is located, the type browser that is accessing the site and the ID number of any cookies on your computer previously placed by that server.

2.3 How Information Collected About You Is Used

Information collected by SBMD about you is used by SBMD to:

  • administer your account,
  • provide you with access to particular tools and services,
  • respond to your inquiries you send to us,
  • obtain your feedback about the SBMD Site or our offerings,
  • statistically analyze user behavior and activity including how frequently areas of the site are visited and how many emails are received and opened,
  • provide you with more relevant content or advertising on the SBMD Site; and
  • conduct research and measurement activities, including those described below.

SBMD may combine personal and non-personal information collected by SBMD about you, and may combine this information with information from external sources. We may also use cookies in order to enable us to conduct surveys for our own use and on behalf of our advertisers. These cookies are used to determine whether you have seen certain content or advertising so that we may request your opinions. We may also use cookies to authenticate respondents or to help you pick up where you left off in a survey. If you have cookies disabled you may not be able to participate in some surveys.

2.4 Research and Measurement Activities

Information that SBMD collects about you may be combined by SBMD with other information available to SBMD through third parties for research and measurement purposes, including measuring the effectiveness of content, advertising or programs. This information from other sources may include age, gender, demographic, geographic, personal interests, product purchase activity or other information. We may report aggregate information to our current or prospective advertisers and other business partners.

2.5 Sharing Your Information

Except as described in this privacy policy or as specifically agreed to by you, SBMD will not disclose any personal information it gathers from you through the SBMD Site. We may only release personal information to third parties: (1) to comply with the law; or (2) in special cases, such as in response to a physical threat to you or others, to protect property or defend or assert legal rights. In addition, we may disclose personal information as described below.

2.6 How Do We Secure and Retain Your Information?

We take reasonable security measures to protect the security of your personal information. Despite SBMD's efforts to protect your personal information, there is always some risk that an unauthorized third party may find a way around our security systems or that transmissions of your information over the Internet may be intercepted.

We will retain your Personal Information as long as needed to provide you services. At any time you can remove your Personal Information or instruct us to remove it, but you should be aware that it is not technologically possible to remove each and every record of the information you have provided to SBMD from our servers. We will also retain your personal information as necessary to comply with legal obligations, resolve disputes and enforce our agreements.

2.7 Changes to This Privacy Policy

We reserve the right to change or modify this privacy policy or any of our tools or services at any time and any changes will be effective upon being posted unless we advise otherwise. We encourage you to periodically review this website for the latest information on our privacy practices. If you do not accept the terms of this privacy policy, we ask that you do not register with us and that you do not use the SBMD Site.

2.8 What Choices Do I Have?

Updating and/or Removing Your Personal information

If you do not want your personal information used by SBMD as provided in this privacy policy, you should not register as a member or for any specific tool or application that collects personal information. You can correct, update or review personal information you have previously submitted by going back to the specific tool or application, logging-in and making the desired change. You can also update any personal information you have submitted by contacting us using the contact information listed below.

If you have registered and desire to delete any your personal information you have provided to us from our systems please contact us. Upon your request, we will delete your personal information from our active databases and where feasible from our back-up media to the extent it is feasible to do so. You should be aware that it is not technologically possible to remove each and every record of the information you have provided to the SBMD Site from our servers.

3. Use of Content

SBMD authorizes you to view or download a single copy of the material on this site solely for your personal, noncommercial use if you include the following copyright notice: “©2013, http://advice.doctorbeheshti.com. All rights reserved” and other copyright and proprietary rights notices that are contained in the content.

The content is protected by copyright under both United States and foreign laws. Title to the content remains with SBMD. Any use of the content not expressly permitted by these Terms and Conditions is a breach of these Terms and Conditions and may violate copyright, trademark, and other laws. Content and features are subject to change or termination without notice in the exclsuive discretion of SBMD. All rights not expressly granted herein are reserved to SBMD.

4. Liability of SBMD and any affiliates or associates

The use of this site and the content is at your own risk. When using this site, information may be transmitted over a medium that may be beyond the control and jurisdiction of SBMD and its suppliers. Accordingly, Dr. Sayeh Behesthi and/or SBMD assumes no liability for or relating to the delay, failure, interruption, or corruption of any data or other information transmitted in connection with use of this site.

The SBMD Site and the content are provided on an “as is” basis. SBMD, ITS LICENSORS, AND ITS SUPPLIERS, TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR OTHERWISE, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, NON-INFRINGEMENT OF THIRD PARTIES’ RIGHTS, WARRANTY OF ACCURACY, WARRANTY OF AND FITNESS FOR PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Without limiting the foregoing, SBMD, its licensors, and its suppliers make no representations or warranties about the following:

      1. The accuracy, reliability, completeness, correctness, or timeliness of the Content, of the SBMD Site.

      2. The satisfaction of any government regulations requiring disclosure of information on prescription drug products or the approval or compliance of any software tools with regard to the content contained on the SBMD Site.

In no event shall SBMD, its licensors, its suppliers, or any third parties mentioned on the SBMD Site be liable for any damages (including, without limitation, incidental and consequential damages, personal injury/wrongful death, lost profits, or damages resulting from lost data or business interruption) resulting from the use of or inability to use the SBMD Site or the content, whether based on warranty, contract, tort, or any other legal theory, and whether or not SBMD, its licensors, its suppliers, or any third parties mentioned on the SBMD Site are advised of the possibility of such damages. SBMD, its licensors, its suppliers, or any third parties mentioned on the SBMD Site are not liable for any personal injury, including death, caused by your use or misuse of the Site. Remedies under these Terms and Conditions are exclusive and are limited to those expressly provided for in these Terms and Conditions.

5. User Submissions

5.1 The personal information you submit to SBMD is governed by the SBMD Privacy Policy. To the extent there is an inconsistency between this Agreement and the SBMD Privacy Policy, this Agreement would govern. The Site contains functionality (including blogs, message boards, etc.) that allows users to upload content to the Site. You agree that you will not upload or transmit any communications or content of any type that infringe or violate any rights of any party. By submitting communications or content to the Site, you agree that such submission is non-confidential for all purposes. If you make any such submission you agree that you will not send or transmit to SBMD by email, any communication or content that infringes or violates any rights of any party. If you submit any business information, idea, concept or invention to SBMD by email, you agree such submission is non-confidential for all purposes. If you make any submission to the Site or if you submit any business information, idea, concept or invention to SBMD by email, you automatically grant-or warrant that the owner of such content or intellectual property has expressly granted-SBMD a royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, world-wide nonexclusive license to use, reproduce, create derivative works from, modify, publish, edit, translate, distribute, perform, and display the communication or content in any media or medium, or any form, format, or forum now known or hereafter developed. SBMD may sublicense its rights through multiple tiers of sublicenses. If you wish to keep any business information, ideas, concepts or inventions private or proprietary, do not submit them to SBMD.

5.2 SBMD Community and Member to Member Areas

If you use a Public Area, such as message boards, blogs, Ask The Doctor, you are solely responsible for your own communications, the consequences of posting those communications, and your reliance on any communications found in the Public Areas. SBMD and its licensors are not responsible for the consequences of any communications in the Public Areas. In cases where you feel threatened or believe someone else is in danger, you should contact your local law enforcement agency immediately. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 immediately. In consideration of being allowed to use the Public Areas, you agree that the following actions shall constitute a material breach of these Terms and Conditions:

      1. Using a Public Area for any purpose in violation of the laws;

      2. Posting material that infringes on the intellectual property rights of others;

      3. Posting material that is unlawful, obscene, defamatory, threatening, harassing, abusive, slanderous, hateful, or embarrassing to any other person or entity as determined by SBMD in its sole discretion;

      4. Posting advertisements or solicitations of business;

      5. After receiving a warning, continuing to disrupt the normal flow of dialogue, or posting comments that are not related to the topic being discussed;

      6. Impersonating another person;

      7. Distributing viruses or other harmful computer code;

      8. Harvesting, scraping or otherwise collecting information about others, including email addresses, without their identification for posting or viewing comments;

      9. Allowing any other person or entity to use your identification for posting or viewing comments; or

      10. Engaging in any other conduct that restricts or inhibits any other person from using or enjoying the Site.

SBMD or its licensors have no liability or responsibility to users of the SBMD Site or any other person or entity for performance or nonperformance of the aforementioned activities.

6. Advertisements, Searches, and Links to Other Sites

SBMD may provide links to third-party Site to allow advertisers to respond to certain search terms with advertisements or sponsored content. SBMD does not recommend and does not endorse the content on any third-party websites. SBMD is not responsible for the content of linked third-party sites, sites framed within the SBMD Site, third-party sites provided as search results, or third-party advertisements, and does not make any representations regarding their content or accuracy. Your use of third-party websites is at your own risk and subject to the terms and conditions of use for such sites.

7. Indemnity

You agree to defend, indemnify, and hold SBMD, its officers, directors, employees, agents, licensors, and suppliers, harmless from and against any claims, actions or demands, liabilities and settlements including without limitation, reasonable legal and accounting fees, resulting from, or alleged to result from, your violation of these Terms and Conditions.

8. General

SBMD is based in Newport Beach, California, in the United States of America. SBMD makes no claims that SBMD Site and the Content are appropriate or may be downloaded outside of the United States. Access to the Content may not be legal by certain persons or in certain countries. If you access the SBMD Network from outside the United States, you do so at your own risk and are responsible for compliance with the laws of your jurisdiction. The following provisions survive the expiration or termination of this Agreement for any reason whatsoever: Liability, Indemnity, Jurisdiction, and Complete Agreement.

9. Jurisdiction

You expressly agree that exclusive jurisdiction for any dispute with SBMD, or in any way relating to your use of the SBMD Site, resides in the courts of the State of California, County of Orange, and you further agree and expressly consent to the exercise of personal jurisdiction in the courts of the State of California in connection with any such dispute including any claim involving SBMD or its affiliates, subsidiaries, employees, contractors, officers, directors, telecommunication providers, and content providers. Notwithstanding any other provision, you agree to a final and binding arbitration in Orange County, State of California to resolve any dispute between you and SBMD and/or Dr. Sayeh Beheshti arising from or related to your use of the SBMD Site in any way, shape or form.

These Terms and Conditions are governed by the internal substantive laws of the State of California, without respect to its conflict of laws principles. If any provision of these Terms and Conditions is found to be invalid by any court having competent jurisdiction, the invalidity of such provision shall not affect the validity of the remaining provisions of these Terms and Conditions, which shall remain in full force and effect. No waiver of any of these Terms and Conditions shall be deemed a further or continuing waiver of such term or condition or any other term or condition.

10. Complete Agreement

These Terms and Conditions and the SBMD Privacy Policy constitute the entire agreement between you and SBMD with respect to the use of the SBMD Site, and its content.

×

Disclaimers


DOCTOR LIFE ADVICE IS NOT INTENDED FOR PROVIDING MEDICAL OR PSYCHIATRIC DIAGNOSES OR ADVICE, AND IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR SEEKING THE HELP OF A PHYSICIAN. DOCTOR BEHESHTI, THE AUTHOR OF THE ARTICLES DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL OR PSYCHIATRIC DIGNOSIS, TREATMENT, OR ADVICE ON THIS PAGE.

IF YOU FEEL YOU HAVE A MEDICAL OR PSYCHIATRIC EMERGENCY, PLEASE CALL 911 OR GO TO YOUR NEAREST EMERGENCY ROOM. THIS SITE IS NOT INTENDED FOR PROVIDING EMERGENCY SERVICES OF ANY KIND.

This website contains questions, answers, graphics, drawing, and other content and material, all of which are for informational purposes only, and are public information. Any questions submitted will be reviewed, and if they are to be answered, the content of the question may be edited for purposes of making it easier to read, and to protect the submitters' identity.

The content of this website is not intended for forming a doctor-patient relationship. Whether or not you get a response to your question, you should be aware that you have not formed a doctor-patient relationship with Doctor Beheshti, and she is not liable for your medical and mental health or wellbeing. Use the responses provided on this website at your own risk, and do not use them in place of a physician's advice.

This website is not intended to replace seeking advice from your physicians. Always seek the advice of a physician, psychiatrist, psychologist, or other health care professionals for issues concerning your physical and mental health. If you submit a question which does not get a response, do not consider that as a sign that you should not seek out the care of a physician.

WARNING

ALTHOUGH AT DOCTOR LIFE ADVICE WE RESPECT THE PRIVACY OF ALL INDIVIDUALS, THE CONTENT OF THIS WEBSITE IS COMPLETELY PUBLIC. THE BEST EFFORTS WILL BE MADE TO MAINTAIN YOUR ANONIMITY WHEN YOUR QUESTIONS ARE POSTED ON THE WEBSITE; HOWEVER, PLEASE BE AWARE THAT YOUR QUESTION MAY BE POSTED ON THE SITE WITH MINIMAL MODIFICATION AND WILL BE AVAILABLE TO ANY AND ALL READERS THAT ACCESS THIS WEBSITE. PLEASE TAKE EXTRA CARE TO PROTECT YOUR IDENTITY AND CONFIDENTIALITY WHEN YOU SUBMIT A QUESTION OR INQUIRY. DOCTOR LIFE ADVICE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE IF SOMEONE IDENTIFIES YOU BASED ON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN YOUR QUESTION. YOUR IDTENTIFYING INFORMATION PROVIDED BY YOUR EMAIL, SUCH AS EMAIL ADDRESS, NAME, IP ADDRESS, ETC. WILL ALL BE REMOVED AND DELETED FROM OUR EMAIL ACCOUNT BEFORE YOUR QUESTION IS POSTED.

×

Helpful Resources




×

About Doctor Life Advice

Doctor Beheshti

I am a compassionate and well trained psychiatric doctor, and I spend my days talking to others and helping them with their daily issues and problems. I have come to understand that all of us, regardless of our backgrounds and our life stories - every one of which is unique - share similar wants and needs.

I love my job which allows me to hear unique stories and help each of my clients individually. Although I cannot take the place of your doctor, I would love to hear your story too and perhaps provide some advice that will be useful to you, as well as others that will benefit from your story.

I have a sense of humor which comes through in my writings. Please know that I NEVER intend to make light of anyone's painful or sensitive situation. I only use humor because I think sometimes a smile and a little chuckle can go a long way in helping us feel better.

Doctor Life Advice is written and maintained by Sayeh Beheshti, M.D., M.A., a private practice psychiatrist in Newport Beach, CA.


×